Dr. T & The Women (2000) from Johnny Web (Uncle Scoopy; Greg Wroblewski) |
Dr T (Richard Gere) is a gynecologist of remarkably calm disposition whose office seems to be the central gathering place for all of the women of society, most of whom have too little to occupy their lives, and use the waiting time to renew social acquaintances, plan political action, and show off their new clothes. Some wear their new hats and smoke during gyno exams. |
Dr T is trying to adjust to the fact that his beloved and beautiful wife had a rare type of mental breakdown, and is reverting to childhood before his eyes, while his daughter (Kate Hudson) is trying to plan her wedding. As all that unfolds, he plays some golf and hits on the assistant pro (Helen Hunt), and goes hunting with his buds. Nothing goes as planned with either his wife or his mistress, and when the wedding finally arrives, his lesbian daughter outs herself, and spurns her bridegroom to run off with the maid of honor (Liv Tyler with about 30 extra pounds on her frame). The film is pure Robert Altman, not a straightforward thriller like "Gingerbread Man," but Altman doing it his way with a wandering character study like "Nashville" or "A Wedding" or "Pret a Porter". But this is no Nashville. Why? |
|
If you are familiar with Robert Altman's films, you know that even the best ones are generally meandering. I started to write "unstructured," but decided that simply wasn't fair. His films have a sort of structure, but it is deliberately loose and unorthodox, and is driven by the characters rather than by the plot twists. That sort of filmmaking places a great burden upon the characterization. When the plot is relatively unimportant, as it is in Altman's films, a filmmaker simply has to involve us in the lives he portrays. He needs to present interesting characters in compelling situations. Altman's best flicks do that. M*A*S*H was an absolute phenomenon; "Nashville" was considered by many to be a work of great genius. Other Altman films, like "The Player." "McCabe and Mrs Miller" and "Short Cuts" have been considered great artistic triumphs. But look what he had to work with in those cases: the military establishment, the country music industry, Hollywood, the myth of the West. Those are epic subjects which can be populated by interesting, myth-shattering characters. In contrast, the subject of "Dr T and the Women" is Dallas society women and their hollow lives. Yawn. Well, ol' Bob really rips the cover off that subject, but when he does, there's nothing much worth watching, nothing we care about, and absolutely nothing that we didn't already know. Another problem with this film is that it lacks Altman's usual rich choice of protagonists. Nashville had about a trillion major characters and sub-plots presented by an ensemble, but every scene in Dr. T either features Richard Gere or is about his character's life. If you find Gere as colorless and lifeless as I do, you'll be yawning about 15 minutes into the film. If you look up the word "bland" in the dictionary, Gere's picture must be there. If Gere were not a movie star, and you met him at a party, how could you subsequently tell someone in the next room which guy you met? Oh, he's the guy who ... Who what? We guys rarely say "that good -looking guy" when talking about another guy, but that's about the only identifiable characteristic Gere has. One more problem. The last ten minutes of this film is one of the weirdest sequences ever to appear in a studio picture. Gere gets caught in a tornado (I guess), like Dorothy in "The Wizard of Oz". (Get the obvious symbolism? His whole life feels like he's spinning in a maelstrom). He's spinning around, passes out, and when he wakes up, wherever he is, he is asked to deliver a baby for some Spanish-speaking people. The baby's birth is then shown in clinical close-up detail, as if an educational film for new or prospective mothers. If you've never actually seen that happen, here's your chance. It's a "niņo." The end. Roll credits. Despite the uninvolving subject matter, the bland star, and the surreal ending, it is an Altman film after all, so there are some fine elements which Altman's fans will hang on to and treasure.
Good moments. |
|||||
|
The film's strengths were, however, too few and not strong enough. Let me be direct about the bottom line. I'm a Robert Altman fan who was thrilled to see the great man's career revive in 1992-1993 with "The Player" and "Short Cuts." That notwithstanding, I found this movie to be a waste of time, and as bad an Altman failure as "A Wedding" or "Popeye." |
||||
|
Return to the Movie House home page