Critics are pretty much in agreement that this
is a 4 star effort. Even though it is a little rough
around the edges, partly because of a low budget
($150,000.00), it shows the emergence of a Scorsese
style. This is a must see for the serious filmgoer. Scoop's note: I
won't disagree with Tuna's assertion that you should see
the movie if you are a serious film buff, but I think the
reasons are:
- It
showed what a great director's work looked like
in its earlier stages.
- It
represented a real breakthrough at the time for
personal filmmaking.
- Its
techniques and themes provided the jumping-off
point for Scorsese's career as well as an inspiration for many other
subsequent filmmakers.
- It
introduced De Niro, Keitel and Scorsese to
mainstream audiences.
|
DVD info from Amazon.
Widescreen letterboxed,
1.85:1, plus a fullscreen version
mono sound, no special
features
|
|
It's my
opinion that the four star reviews are for Scorsese's
career, not for this film. It is a good early movie made
by a director who would become great. I think Scorsese
probably regrets some of the techniques he used here.
(Like the filtered lenses) The DVD is a real disappointment.
I'm not sure how much is lost on the DVD compared to the
theatrical presentation, but the sound is poor, and the film is sometimes
blurry and undercontrasted.
The DVD
letterboxed version simply blocks off information at the
top and bottom of the full screen version, and the matting
is not done exactly right, because the ratio is not
exactly 1.85
|
The
Critics Vote
|
The People
Vote ...
- With their
votes ... IMDB summary: IMDb voters
score it 7.6, not far from the top 250.
|
IMDb
guideline: 7.5 usually indicates a level of
excellence, about like three and a half stars
from the critics. 6.0 usually indicates lukewarm
watchability, about like two and a half stars
from the critics. The fives are generally not
worthwhile unless they are really your kind of
material, about like two stars from the critics.
Films under five are generally awful even if you
like that kind of film, equivalent to about one
and a half stars from the critics or less,
depending on just how far below five the rating
is. |
|