This is a four-part
Russian TV series about the last two years in the life
of the most important Russian tsar, Peter the Great, or
Big Pete as I like to call him. Actually, I like to call
him Peter the Great by Russian Standards, a
qualification which annoys the hell out of my Russian
relatives. Based on a semi-historical novel by the
venerable Daniil Granin, this series centers around
Peter's relationship with Maria
Cantemir, a beautiful and well educated young
Moldavian princess who became Peter's last mistress and
possibly his greatest love, at least if you believe the
screenplay. According to the novel and this series,
Cantemir become pregnant with Peter's child, whereupon
Empress Catherine conspired with Cantemir's physician to
abort the pregnancy before Peter could name the child as
his heir.
(NOTE: The English Wikipedia page
linked above offers minimal info about Cantemir. If you
want some detail about her, switch to the Russian
version of her Wikipedia page, then translate it into
English.)
The story presented here is
essentially a collection of all the most lurid tidbits
of gossip from the Russian court in that era. I believe
it is a fair analogy to say that this story bears the
same relationship to history as the famous BBC series
"I, Claudius," in that the basic outline of the story
does not contradict what we know to be true, but the
screenplay embellishes the facts and fills in the
details in the juiciest possible way. Just as with the
Suetonius version of ancient Rome presented by "I,
Claudius," we aren't even very sure that what we "know
to be true" about Peter's era is actually true, because
it was not any wiser for a contemporary to print
something unfavorable about Peter the Great than it was
to do so about Caligula. Most historians and journalists
prefer the fashion statement they can make with their
heads attached to their bodies. So it was in tsarist
Russia, as it was in imperial Rome, that many events
were never recorded by an objective contemporary
observer. This TV series recounts, for example, the
heroic tale of how Peter the Great died from an illness
he incurred by his nearly superhuman effort to save some
common sailors from icy water. Although that story is
widely believed, many historians feel that it was
entirely concocted. Similarly, very little is really
known about Maria Cantemir's relationship with the Tsar,
which was conducted away from prying eyes because he was
married to another woman at the time. It is possible
that the empress ordered Peter's mistress to be
poisoned, but it is also possible that no such order
ever existed. Some historians claim that the child was
born, but died in early infancy, unremarkably, as so
many children did in those days. (Peter and Catherine
had eleven children over a 19-year period, of which only
one lived past her 21st birthday. That one became
empress of Russia some 16 years after her father died,
and ruled for more than twenty years.)
The show is not without humor. It is a running theme in
the film, that people are constantly being punished and
executed in the public square for some crimes against
God or Russia or both. As they execute a seemingly
endless parade of local governors and mayors, the
ceremonial executioners are perpetually reading aloud
from long lists of crimes both grand and petty. I don't
know enough about the Russian sense of humor to know
whether this interminable droning of details, specifying
events of wildly contrasting gravity (like "conspiring
to assassinate the Tsar and chewing gum in church"), was
actually supposed to be funny, but these scenes closely
resemble the Tuco execution scenes in The Good the Bad
and the Ugly, and I found this to be an amusing backdrop
to the story.
Anyway, I guess that a Russian version of "I, Claudius"
is not such a bad idea. As presented here, the
machinations of the courtiers are entertaining and often
funny, Peter's mistress looks great with her clothes off
and on, and some of the revenge plots shown here would
not be out of place in a Quentin Tarantino movie. You
may well enjoy this if you value sensationalized mass
entertainment over scrupulous historical accuracy.
|
Our Grade:
If you are not familiar with our grading system, you
need to read the explanation,
because the grading is not linear. For example, by our
definition, a C is solid and a C+ is a VERY good movie.
There are very few Bs and As. Based on our descriptive
system, this film is a:
C
Not historically reliable, but lurid enough to be
entertaining.
|