Additional info:

For the purpose of further studies and comparisons, consider the following list of the top ten finishers from each year since the polls began (I broke ties arbitrarily), and in the "retro" years of 1995-1998. The links in the first column lead to the actual results pages for those years, but the years before 2012 do not include video links except for the retro polls (1995-1998).
Year 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1995
 Alyssa Milano
 Elizabeth Berkley
 Mimi Rogers
 Molly Ringwald
 Natasha Henstridge
 Salma Hayek
 Holly Marie Combs
 Sophie Marceau
 Elisabeth Shue
 Anne Heche
1996
 Jennifer Connelly
 Kate Winslet
 Alyssa Milano
 Ashley Judd
 Kelly MacDonald
 Liv Tyler
 Teri Hatcher
 Catherine Bell
 Demi Moore
 Indira Varma
1997
 Heather Graham
 Jennifer Connelly
 Charlize Theron
 Jaime Pressly
 Connie Nielsen
 Kari Wuhrer
 Jessica Hecht
 Kate Winslet
 Helena Bonham Carter
 Patricia Arquette
1998 Angelina Jolie
 Reese Witherspoon
 Rachel Weisz
 Denise Richards
 Alex Kingston
 Elizabeth Mitchell
 Gwyneth Paltrow
 Holly Hunter
 Melissa George
 Asia Argento
1999 Shannon Elizabeth Rene Russo Nicole Kidman Thora Birch Mena Suvari Hudson Leick Tara Reid Julianne Moore Halle Berry Ashley Judd
2000 Katie Holmes Amanda Peet Jennifer Connelly Amy Smart Gretchen Mol Laetitia Casta Peta Wilson Alex Kingston Jennifer Connelly Michelle Williams
2001 Halle Berry Halle Berry Laura Linney Leelee Sobieski Piper Perabo Rachel Miner Angelina Jolie Monica Bellucci Daryl Hannah Kari Wuhrer
2002 Heather Graham Salma Hayek Diane Lane Dominique Swain Rebecca Romijn Emily Mortimer Maggie Gyllenhaal Selma Blair Paz Vega Kate Winslet
2003 Christina Ricci Charlotte Ross Chloe Hunter Justine Bateman Meg Ryan Nikki Ziering Leelee Sobieski Amanda Swisten Ludivine Sagnier Josie Davis
2004 Eva Green Mimi Rogers Chloe Sevigny Neve Campbell Jordan Ladd Rosario Dawson Natalie Portman Juliette Lewis Mia Kirshner Maggie Gyllenhaal
2005 Anne Hathaway Carla Gugino Alexis Dziena Margo Stilley Bryce Howard Kelly Brook Polly Walker Jennifer Esposito Mia Kirshner Alison Lohman
2006 Gretchen Mol Salma Hayek Brittany Daniel Maggie Gyllenhaal Lauren Lee Smith Sarah Polley Sook Yin Lee Sharon Stone Robin Tunney Jennifer Aniston
2007 Christina Ricci Marisa Tomei Natalie Portman Michelle Borth Madeline Zima Gillian Anderson Heather Graham Alice Henley Keeley Hazell Sienna Miller
2008 Anna Paquin Marisa Tomei Eliza Dushku Lizzy Caplan Mary-Louise Parker Mischa Barton Danneel Harris Mena Suvari Laetitia Casta Anna Faris
2009 Eva Amurri Anna Paquin Jessica Biel Alice Eve Amber Heard Lucy Lawless Michelle Williams Victoria Abril Betsy Rue Paz de la Huerta
2010 Amanda Seyfried Anne Hathaway Mary-Louise Parker Kirsten Dunst Paz de la Huerta Viva Bianca Kelly Brook Emmy Rossum Christina Ricci Rebecca Creskoff
2011 Emmy Rossum Kirsten Dunst Emily Browning Lake Bell Autumn Reeser Lucy Lawless/Jaime Murray Deborah Revy Kathleen Robertson Rooney Mara Emilia Clarke
2012 Sarah Silverman Olivia Munn Helen Hunt Nadine Velazquez Kristen Stewart Ali Cobrin Laura Prepon Dreama Walker Camilla Luddington Michelle Williams
2013 Rosario Dawson Emily Ratajkowski Shiri Appleby Riki Lindhome Amanda Seyfried Lizzy Caplan Elizabeth Moss Laura Prepon Adele Exarchopolous Emilia Clarke
2014 Alexandra Daddario Scarlett Johansson Nathalie Emmanuel Lili Simmons Stacy Martin Margot Robbie Emily Ratajkowski Shailene Woodley Jessica Chastain Reese Witherspoon
2015
 		Alicia Vikander
 		Ruby Rose
 		Sasha Alexander
 		Charisma Carpenter
 		Eliza Coupe
 		Kristen Wiig
 		Dakota Johnson
 		Sarah Silverman
 		Rosabell Sellers
 		Emily Kinney
2016 YYvonne Strahovski
 Ellen Page
 Thandie Newton
 Olivia Wilde
 Kate Micucci Ashley Greene
 Eliza Dushku
 Ellen Page
 Emilia Clarke
 Imogen Poots
2017
 Alison Brie
 Lily James
 Nathalie Emmanuel
 Lucy Hale
 Kristen Stewart
 Carrie Coon
 Emmy Rossum
 Christina Ricci
 Marion Cotillard
 Louisa Krause
2018
 Sally Hawkins
 Jennifer Lawrence
 Rosamund Pike
 Martha Higareda
 Dichen Lachman
 Betty Gilpin
 Emma Stone
 Ophelie Bau
 Aya Wolf
 Addison Timlin
2019 Kate Mara
 Sydney Sweeney
 Margaret Qualley
 Alison Brie
 Paula Beer
 Aimee-Lou Wood
 Erin Moriarty
 Anya Chalotra
 Kelli Berglund
 Maisie Williams
2020 Winslet/Ronan
 Alison Brie
 Matilda De Angelis
 Jamie Chung
 Margaret Qualley
 Thomasin McKenzie
 Daisy Edgar-Jones
 Alexandra Daddario
 Ida Engvoll
 Noemie Merlant
2021 Sydney Sweeney Sarah Shahi Maryse Miege
 Megan Montaner
 Alexa Miro Lea Seydoux
 Mizuhara/Sato Sydney Meyer Odessa Young
 Noemie Merlant
2022 Maia Mitchell
 Brittany Snow
 Sydney Sweeney Emma Corrin
 Ana de Armas
 Willa Fitzgerald
 Ashley Greene
 Emma Thompson
 Kelly Reilly
 Judy Greer
2023 Jennifer Lawrence
 Emma Stone
 Alison Brie Shelley Hennig
 Ana Girardot
 Virginia Efira
 Lily-Rose Depp
 Shailene Woodley Betty Gilpin
 Alyson Gorske